The 5 components that decide politics and voting behaviour in Manipur 

Imphal: Vociferous protests demanding the elimination of Armed Forces Particular Powers Act (AFSPA) and calling for the implementation of the Internal Line Allow, and the nagging drawback of insurgency, one thing that claimed the lives of an Assam Rifles commanding officer and his household by the hands of militants in November — Manipur has been within the headlines for someday now.

Nonetheless, as Manipur goes to the polls within the first stage of the meeting elections Monday (the second stage of polling is on 5 March), these points haven’t taken centrestage within the ballot campaigning of the varied events within the fray. 

Geographically, hilly areas comprise 90 per cent of the Northeastern state, largely inhabited by tribals, whereas the ethnic Meitei group dominates the valley areas, which make up 10 per cent of the overall land space. 

Whereas Meiteis make up 53 per cent of the inhabitants, tribals — which primarily embrace the Nagas (24 per cent) and the Kuki-Zo (16 per cent) — represent 41 per cent. 

A lot of Manipur’s political panorama has been marked by variations between these numerous ethnic teams. Including to that is an unstable political tradition characterised by defections. 

Competing guarantees of growth and a large inflow of cash in politics are necessary components too.

A longstanding separatist insurgency in addition to clashes between numerous rebel teams, nonetheless, has all the time solid a shadow on the state’s affairs.

ThePrint lists the varied components to elucidate how electoral politics have performed out within the state. 

Additionally learn: Defections, flailing management, pockets of hope — how Congress ‘khubak’ declined in Manipur

Violent insurgency & AFSPA

Insurgency has been a fundamental concern within the state from even earlier than it had attained statehood in 1972. 

The many years from 1960 noticed the rise of the United Nationwide Liberation Entrance (UNLF), Individuals’s Revolutionary Get together of Kangleipak (PREPAK) and Individuals’s Liberation Military of Manipur (PLA) — separatist teams that declare that the merger of Manipur with the Union of India had been a “pressured” one. Including to the combo have been the tribal militias — the Naga and Kuki rebel teams.

Essentially the most important among the many Naga teams is the Nationwide Socialist Council of Nagaland (Isak-Muivah), which arose from the Naga motion for self-determination within the Naga inhabited areas of the Northeast. They demand a united homeland for Nagas — the ‘Larger Nagalim’ — together with Naga-inhabited areas in Assam, Arunachal Pradesh and Manipur. 

The group continues to carry large sway within the Naga dominated hill areas of Manipur — significantly Ukhrul. In truth, the Tangkhul Naga village of Somdal in Manipur has been the birthplace of many rebel leaders, together with NSCN (I-M) basic secretary Th. Muivah. 

In the meantime, the foundation of the Kuki insurgency within the state may be traced again to the Nineteen Fifties, when the Kuki Nationwide Military (KNA) was fashioned to guard the rights and pursuits of the Kukis towards “incursions” by each the Meiteis and the Nagas.

Manipur, for the reason that time it was merged with India in 1949, has been witness to violent flare ups between these teams, together with the Naga-Kuki clashes that occurred within the Nineteen Nineties. 

The entire of Manipur was declared a “disturbed space” in 1980 and the AFSPA imposed, entitling safety forces some particular powers. 

The Act, nonetheless, gained notoriety within the state over cases of alleged excesses by safety forces. Extra important amongst them was the notorious 1987 counter-insurgency operation, codenamed ‘Bluebird’, in Senapati district, whereby “many males have been maimed, tortured and ladies raped”. 

Then in 2004, two years after Congress’ Okram Ibobi Singh rose to energy, there was the horrific rape and homicide of 32-year-old Manorama, allegedly by paramilitary troopers, which prompted the well-known protest by 12 ladies, who disrobed in entrance of the historic Kangla fort. 

Whereas the difficulty of the AFSPA’s elimination, a longstanding demand within the state, finds a point out within the manifestos of the Congress, the Naga Individuals’s Entrance and Nationwide Individuals’s Get together, its absence from the ruling BJP’s manifesto has attracted criticism. 

The BJP, nonetheless, at totally different factors this election season, has referred to those points to focus on its rivals. 

BJP nationwide president J.P. Nadda, as an illustration, is reported to have stated, “Insurgency and AFSPA had all the time been necessary points. Nonetheless, in latest occasions, we now have been in a position to deliver insurgency to a naked minimal which ushered in a state of peace and normalcy within the state.”

As a counter, the Congress in Manipur has maintained that the state authorities beneath Okram Ibobi Singh, whose regime witnessed a peak in insurgency exercise, was liable for the repeal of AFSPA in seven meeting constituencies straddling Imphal. 

The issue of insurgency additionally underlined Amit Shah’s latest go to to the hill district of Churachandpur, house of many Kuki teams, the place the Union house minister vowed to finish the militancy drawback if the BJP comes again to energy.

By the way, it was on this district final November that 5 Assam Rifles troopers, together with a commanding officer and his spouse, have been killed in an ambush by militants.

Dominant Meitei politics

Of the 60 meeting seats in Manipur, the valley areas are represented by 40 seats, whereas the hills are represented by 20. 

In consequence, the Meiteis, who reside within the valleys, have wielded extra political affect within the state — a reality that’s on the root of the prevailing hill-valley divide.

As an example, out of the 12 chief ministers elected within the state since 1963, solely two have been from (Naga) tribal communities (Yangmasho Shaiza and Rishang Keishang). 

Until 2017, the valley constituencies had primarily voted for Congress and,in some circumstances, regional events just like the Manipur Individuals’s Get together, an offshoot of the Congress. 

Within the valleys, clan affiliations play a major function when it comes to voting behaviour. 

The Meiteis primarily comprise the Meitei Hindus, the Meitei Sanamahi (these following the normal Meitei faith, which existed previous to the erstwhile princely kingdom’s conversion to Hinduism) and the Meitei Muslims or Pangals as they’re identified. 

Researchers Oinam Bhagat and A. Bimol Akoijam of their 2002 paper “Meeting Election: Developments and Points” had famous that “for the Meiteis, the voting sample will not be based mostly on no matter non secular divide that exists amongst them”. As an alternative, “within the valley, to some extent, clan lineage performs a vital function” and there are “tendencies the place individuals of a clan demographically distributed in a cluster (significantly in rural areas) are inclined to vote for a candidate near their kin”. 

In some components of Imphal and in rural areas, the clans reside of their respective leikais or neighbourhoods. 

Assist for a Congress candidate in Wangkhem by way of a apply referred to as athenpot thinba | Photograph: Praveen Jain | ThePrint

In a Congress rally ThePrint visited final week in Wangkhem constituency in Thoubal district, there was a collective present of assist for a candidate. Through the rally, ladies from the identical leikai have been seen strolling into the rally in single information carrying bamboo baskets with choices of rice, flowers, vegetables and fruit. This royal period apply, referred to as athenpot thinba, is usually an indication of assist for the candidate. 

Apparently, Akoijam, an assistant professor at JNU, instructed ThePrint that over time the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), which has existed within the state for the reason that Nineteen Fifties, have turn into extra energetic amongst Meiteis within the valleys. 

“However the Meiteis are a gaggle of revivalists, so there’s an anti-brahmanical ethos, though the RSS is making an attempt to current it as the identical conglomeration,” he stated. 

“I don’t assume although that hardcore Hindutva undertaking will work right here,” he added.

The revivalist motion in Manipur began in 1944, geared toward preserving Meitei heritage and reconstructing Metei identification. 

Tribal politics 

In contrast to within the valley areas, the Congress wasn’t the dominant get together within the hills. 

Three perceived “anti-hill” payments in 2015 — Safety of Manipur Peoples Invoice, the Manipur Land Income and Land Reforms (Seventh Modification) Invoice and Manipur Outlets and Institutions (Second Modification) Invoice — handed within the aftermath of the Meitei-led protests for Internal Line Allow contributed to some discontentment in the direction of the Congress.

The Okram Ibobi Singh Congress authorities’s transfer to disclaim the entry of NSCN(I-M) chief Th. Muivah into Manipur in 2010 additionally created disaffection.

But, the Congress nonetheless stays a contender, previous meeting election outcomes point out. 

Some meeting seats within the hill areas have been gained prior to now by the Congress and the state-based offshoots of the Congress just like the Manipur Individuals’s Get together. The Nationwide Individuals’s Get together, the Naga Individuals’s Entrance and independents have additionally gained within the hills. 

Then, within the 2017 meeting polls, the BJP managed to win 5 hill seats, a primary for the get together, whereas the Congress wrested 9 seats.

Bhagat and Akoijam of their paper say that “the groupings based mostly on tribal identification performed a vital function within the hills”. 

Akoijam of JNU instructed ThePrint that “underground teams” wield appreciable affect in these areas in terms of voting. 

“The mainstream political events can resist underground affect however are much less able to doing the identical factor within the hills,” he stated. “As an example, the Naga concern is being propped up by the underground teams. However, it doesn’t essentially point out the recognition of the Naga concern,” he added.

The aggressive growth agenda

Forward of the Meeting elections, the contesting political events have constantly introduced up the difficulty of growth in Manipur. 

Political instability, the state’s troubles with insurgency in addition to the tough hill terrain has meant that the state has scored low on financial indicators. 

The 2020-2021 Financial Survey report for the state revealed that per capita earnings stays effectively beneath the nationwide common. 

Improvement within the hills has significantly lagged behind when it comes to street connectivity and entry to healthcare, additional accentuating the hill-valley divide. 

In an try to garner extra assist within the hills, the BJP in September final yr revived its ‘Go To Hills’ outreach marketing campaign — an initiative to deliver state authorities advantages to individuals within the distant areas. 

BJP leaders in a number of speeches have additionally propounded on how they’ve “bridged the hill-valley divide”.

Street connectivity in hilly areas like Ukhrul continues to be an issue | Photograph: Praveen Jain | ThePrint

In his rallies in Imphal, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has claimed that the “double-engine” BJP authorities beneath the Chief Minister N. Biren Singh reworked Manipur from a “blockade state” into one prepared with routes for worldwide commerce. 

In his tackle, Modi was referring to the indefinite financial blockade that had been referred to as by the United Naga Council in 2016 following the controversial formation of seven new districts. 

In the meantime, former CM Okram Ibobi Singh of the Congress has countered the BJP’s claims of growth in his rallies, saying most such initiatives had been initiated beneath his regime, from 2002 to 2017.

Cash energy and defections

One other issue that has colored Manipur politics has been fixed defections of politicians. 

Bhagat and Akoijam of their paper observe that the “change of get together loyalty, shifting alliances, each within the particular person and collective ranges, are frequent and ruthless” since Manipur attained statehood in 1972. 

There have been, the paper notes, “as many as eight chief ministers, with frequent adjustments of guard, on 18 events”.

Within the final 5 years too, a sequence of defections has plagued the Congress, which ended up shedding 15 of its 28 legislators to different events. 

The rationale, consultants say, is that political ideologies inside the realm of electoral politics seldom maintain floor within the state. 

As an alternative, what’s essential is “cash, persona and gun tradition”, says Pradip Phanjoubam, editor of Imphal Overview of Arts and Politics

Akoijam additionally added, “The move of cash has elevated [in this elections]. That is large and unprecedented. Primarily, it’s from the BJP, which has scaled up its funding, so others are pressured to observe go well with.” 

In ThePrint’s journey by way of the state forward of the meeting polls, it was evident that these numerous faultlines have removed from been bridged in the course of the five-year-long BJP authorities beneath N. Biren Singh. 

However, with the Congress nonetheless struggling to regroup, the jury stays out on whether or not the state will see a change of guard.

(Edited by Saikat Niyogi)

Additionally learn: Congress open to alliance with BJP’s associate & Manipur rival NPP, says ex-CM Ibobi Singh


Supply hyperlink