Why stakes are excessive as BMC comes underneath administrator with out elected members after 40 years


Mumbai: In 2017, Malishka, a preferred radio jockey with a personal FM station, launched a viral video mocking the Brihanmumbai Municipal Company’s (BMC) monsoon preparedness with a track, “Mumbai, Tula BMC var bharosa nahi kay? (Mumbai, don’t you belief the BMC?)”, elaborating on town’s potholed roads and annual floods.

Whereas no one from the BMC admitted it on file, the viral video is believed to have damage the Shiv Sena-ruled civic physique to such an extent that it despatched Malishka’s mom, Lily Mendosa, a discover for mosquito breeding in her home.

On file, the BMC stated it didn’t comprehend it was Malishka’s home and the breeding was discovered throughout a routine inspection. However, a number of corporators from the ruling physique and members of the civic administration spoke in hushed tones about how the motion was no coincidence.

Pockmarked roads and knee-deep water is an correct description of each Mumbaikar’s actuality throughout the monsoon yearly. The BMC’s motion, nevertheless, maybe got here from a sentiment of overwhelm.

Organised into 24 administrative wards with 227 directly-elected public representatives and a inhabitants of 1.28 crore to serve, the BMC has a variety of duties — from managing Mumbai’s sanitation, sewerage and water provide to establishing and sustaining roads, parks, markets and main hospitals.

Furthermore, the company has additionally taken up advanced capital and time-intensive showpiece tasks such because the Brimstowad that entails an improve of storm water drains, a coastal highway challenge by reclaiming land in Mumbai for the primary time because the 1991 Coastal Regulation Zone notification, and an east-west highway challenge involving tunnels. Previously, it has additionally constructed a dam to reinforce Mumbai’s energy provide, and is now planning a hybrid hydro and solar energy plant on it.

From Tuesday, this behemoth got here underneath a single administrator for the primary time in almost 4 a long time, with the time period of the publicly elected basic physique lapsing on 7 March.


Additionally learn: Rs 17,000 cr revamp for Mumbai’s British-era BDD chawls: Residents hopeful, planners have doubts


‘Corporators will change into common residents’

With polls to the Mumbai civic physique delayed as a result of reorganisation of ward boundaries, the Uddhav Thackeray-led Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) authorities of Maharashtra accredited an modification to the Mumbai Municipal Company Act final month, to facilitate the appointment of an administrator.

The polls are additionally more likely to be delayed as a result of Supreme Court docket’s scrapping of the Different Backward Courses quota in native physique elections, and there being a political demand to revive it.

In keeping with the state cupboard’s determination, municipal commissioner Iqbal Singh Chahal will act because the administrator.

A BMC official who didn’t want to be named stated that completely different committees of corporators that used to debate and advocate proposals for approval to the civic physique on issues reminiscent of schooling, land use and so forth, will stop to exist.

“The BMC had an administrator as soon as in 1984-85 for a 12 months. From Tuesday, corporators will change into common residents. They received’t have entry to their workplaces, they received’t have the ability to use their letterheads. In the event that they want to convey one thing to the administrator’s discover or get some specific work finished, it turns into the administrator’s alternative to offer them a listening to, and never a compulsion,” the official added.

A complete of 15 civic our bodies for which elections have been to be held this 12 months could have directors. However the BMC stands out because of its sheer measurement, expansive funds, the form of multi-crore tasks it undertakes, and the magnitude of the inhabitants it governs.

Finances increased than eight states, plush reserves

Madhav Pai, govt director of analysis physique WRI India, informed ThePrint: “Cities in Maharashtra and Gujarat are ruled by municipal Acts created earlier than Independence. Firms have a variety of energy. In Bangalore, for instance, topics reminiscent of water and transport are dealt with by the state authorities. In Mumbai, these are with the BMC.”

“As a result of land worth is so excessive in Mumbai, through the years, property tax income for the BMC has been fairly sizeable. In consequence, the BMC has cash, which drives good decentralised ward-level governance and good employees as effectively,” Pai added.

Within the ongoing fiscal 12 months, the BMC’s revenue from property tax is anticipated to be Rs 7,000 crore.

The BMC’s 2021-22 funds of Rs 39,038.83 crore was greater than the budgets of eight state governments, particularly Tripura, Nagaland, Mizoram, Meghalaya, Manipur, Arunachal Pradesh, Sikkim and Goa.

It’s 2022-23 funds, accredited final month, is the very best ever thus far, Rs 45,949.21 crore.

Over time, the BMC’s share of capital expenditure within the whole funds has been on the rise because it spends extra on creating and sustaining public infrastructure.

Allocation for capital expenditure has surged to 49 per cent of the funds in 2022-23, from 19 per cent in 2016-17. The BMC’s precise spend on capital expenditure additionally surged 114 per cent to Rs 8237.13 crore in 2020-21, from 3850.46 crore in 2016-17. Within the ongoing fiscal, the capital expenditure is anticipated to shoot up additional to Rs 16866.48 crore.

In his funds speech, Chahal stated: “Contemplating the growing liabilities of ongoing tasks, particular tasks and compulsory duties, large quantities shall be required sooner or later to fulfill capital expenditure in addition to income expenditure. Additionally, there shall be want of sizeable funds for repairs and upgradation of those services sooner or later.”

Taking on of capital-intensive works has been doable for the BMC because of its excessive pile of reserves, which Chahal stated have now been linked to infrastructure tasks to “make sure that reserves are funnelled in direction of capital expenditure to enhance infrastructure for residents in Mumbai”.

In keeping with the 2022-23 funds presentation, the BMC has out there reserves of Rs 55,807.68 crore.


Additionally learn: BJP MLA slams Mumbai civic physique for organising welfare centre for dabbwalas removed from railway station


Excessive-profile, multi-crore tasks

The BMC’s most bold and high-profile challenge is at the moment a coastal freeway, which it’s establishing from Marine Drive in south Mumbai to the Worli finish of the Bandra-Worli sea hyperlink.

The ten.58-km coastal highway, being constructed at a value of Rs 12,950 crore, entails a novel undersea tunnel, touted to be the nation’s first. To make this doable, the BMC has procured India’s largest tunnel-boring machine, which it has named ‘Mavala (soldier)’. The BMC is reclaiming 111 hectares from the Arabian Sea to make the coastal highway and open areas round it.

BMC
BMC’s coastal highway challenge in progress | Photograph: Ashwini Bhide/Twitter

This 12 months, the company’s highest funds allocation was for the coastal highway challenge, for which it put aside Rs 3,500 crore.

The civic physique has additionally made massive allocations for the Goregaon-Mulund Hyperlink Street challenge and the Mumbai Sewage Disposal challenge involving Rs 1,300 crore and Rs 1,340 crore, respectively.

The Goregaon-Mulund highway challenge, a key east-west connector, entails establishing new roads, widening current ones, constructing flyovers in addition to 4.7-km twin tunnels underneath the ecologically delicate Sanjay Gandhi Nationwide Park. It additionally entails rehabilitating greater than 700 households and 50 business buildings.

The Mumbai Sewage Disposal challenge, estimated to value greater than Rs 16,000 crore, entails organising seven sewage remedy crops of a cumulative capability of two,464 million litres a day.

In addition to this, the BMC is within the technique of organising a desalination plant.

Political energy centres

City planner Sulakshana Mahajan informed ThePrint that “the BMC virtually capabilities like an arm of the state authorities”.

“All its main insurance policies go to the federal government for approval. Politically, the BMC is seen as vital because it helps in getting a stake within the functioning of the state authorities,” Mahajan stated.

She, nevertheless, added that the rights of the company are restricted, with the state being the ultimate authority on vital coverage points. She cited how, in 2015, the Devendra Fadnavis-led Maharashtra authorities had scrapped the draft Mumbai improvement plan ready by the BMC and appointed a committee to formulate a brand new one.

One other Mumbai-based city planning professional who didn’t want to be named stated that issues are clean if it’s the identical political social gathering dominant within the state authorities in addition to the BMC.

“When that has not been the case, political events have tried to construct their very own energy centres in Mumbai. They’ve created different authorities to the BMC, weakening the civic physique, in order that they will even have a grip over Mumbai’s improvement,” he stated.

He gave examples of how our bodies such because the Mumbai Metropolitan Area Growth Authority (MMRDA) and the Maharashtra Housing and Space Growth Authority (MHADA) have been created within the Seventies, and later strengthened through the years.

Each our bodies have been appointed as particular planning authorities in numerous areas of Mumbai, with the MMRDA having management over plush actual property within the Bandra Kurla Advanced and Wadala, amongst different locations, and MHADA having the authority to approve constructing plans on its land.

Furthermore, the MMRDA maintains a number of main roads within the metropolis such because the arterial Jap and Western Categorical Highways.

Mahajan stated: “At any time when there’s been a conflict between the BMC and the state authorities, the latter has given our bodies reminiscent of MMRDA and MHADA extra powers as an answer. This type of fractured governance is a particularly poor organisational construction for a metropolis like Mumbai. The large budgets then don’t make any distinction.”

Even within the RJ Malishka episode of 2017, Shiv Sena members had cited these jurisdiction wars within the BMC’s defence.

Two leaders of the Aaditya Thackeray-led Yuva Sena had urged then BMC commissioner Ajoy Mehta to file a Rs 500 crore defamation swimsuit in opposition to the radio jockey. They stated she was unfairly blaming the BMC for issues that weren’t underneath the civic physique’s jurisdiction.

(Edited by Nida Fatima Siddiqui)


Additionally learn: Mumbai Police recordsdata grievance over false IT raid on BMC commissioner Iqbal Chahal




Supply hyperlink